Sunday, April 12, 2015

Kangaroo Court: The 2015 Wide Receivers

When the computer looked at the wide receiver prospects in 2013, it had some serious doubts about the majority of the top selections.  Then, in 2014, the computer generally agreed with the mainstream view that the top wide receiver prospects were a rather interesting group of players.  This year, Reilly and I were actually somewhat tempted to not to make this list at all.  There were just so many gray areas to so many of this year's top prospects, that we really started to feel a bit uncomfortable.

It's not that this year's prospects are bad.  They aren't.  In fact, there were more wide receivers who passed through our filters this year, than in any year in recent memory.  Despite that, it was hard to say that there were many wide receivers who we would confidently argue were clearly destined for greatness.  Instead, we found a lot of players whom the computer just projected to be 'okay'...maybe.  With the expectations for where a lot of these players are supposedly going to be selected, this led us to feel a bit more worried about the potential value of this year's crop.  In the end, someone is almost certainly going to emerge as a future star, but this just feels like a draft class where a lot of the top prospects might be more likely to become good number 2 receivers, rather than the terrifying monsters that their draft status might lead you to hope they would be.  More than we would normally like to see, this group feels much more vulnerable to the unknown factor of what team they end up playing for.

So, as we have done before, we will contemplate every wide receiver prospect who managed to produce both a Stat Score and an Athletic Score, that was no worse than -0.100 standard deviations below average.  The receivers will be divided into two groups, one for players that are over 200# (the 'Big' receivers), and those who are under 210# (the 'Small' receivers).  For players who fit in both groups (players who are between 200 and 210 pounds), we'll test them in both groups to see where they might fit best.  For 'Small' receivers, the computer puts more of an emphasis on speed and agility when forming their Athletic Score, and their Stat Scores is more demanding of multiple seasons of solid statistical production.  For the 'Big' receivers, the computer places more of an emphasis on power (the dreaded Kangaroo Score), and their Stat Score is somewhat less demanding.  We'll also filter out any 'Big' receivers with 40-times below 4.60 seconds, as well as filtering out 'Small' receivers with 40-times below 4.50 seconds.



Big Receiver            Stat Score    Athletics Score
Devante Davis -0.013 0.397
Jaelen Strong 0.426 1.192
Kevin White 0.201 0.584
Breshad Perriman 0.481 0.773
Deontay Greenberry 0.166 0.198
DeVante Parker 0.191 0.267
Jordan Taylor -0.083 -0.084
Da'Ron Brown -0.070 0.156
R.J. Harris 0.966 0.098
Geremy Davis 0.113 0.616




Small Receiver            Stat Score    Athletics Score
Tre McBride 0.415 0.628
Tyrell Williams 0.484 0.504
DeAndre Carter 0.726 0.518
Amari Cooper 0.462 0.517
Nelson Agholor 0.428 -0.023



Just to be clear, these filters are only intended to identify the players that the computer thinks have the best chance of becoming 'average' NFL receivers.  Our definition of average is a player that can produce 35 receiving yards per game played over the course of their career (or a modest 560 receiving yards over 16 games), so our standards are fairly low.  If we raised our standards to players who averaged at least 45 receiving yards per games played, it really becomes quite rare for a player not to pass both of these statistical hurdles.  We wouldn't take the scores listed above too seriously, as they are really scores that are built upon many smaller scores, which frequently matter even more.  This is just how we start the weeding out process, to determine which players we want to focus our attention on.  In reality, we always end up having to veto some of the computer's recommendations for various reasons, which we will try to describe as we go along.  Unfortunately, our own worthless and subjective opinion does come into play a bit more on these vetoes.

In last year's post, we also mentioned that we were intending to make some changes to our filters, that we hoped would improve the accuracy of our hunches.  Mainly, we wanted to make agility measurements a more significant factor for Big receivers.  We've also been thinking about tweaking some of the numbers for small receivers, because we tend to be a bit harsh with with those guys.  Unfortunately, umm, we kind of forgot to get around to doing this.  So, at least for this year, our filters have largely remained the same, though I suppose that gives us something to do in the upcoming season.

There is one other thing that we should probably mention.  While it doesn't get discussed very much, there is a wide receiver in this draft class who is named Jazz King, who played at Marshall.  The computer doesn't find him very appealing, but I think a good argument can be made that this is the type of name that merits a 1st round pick.  I mean, if I can pick horses for the Preakness based on their names, I don't see why that wouldn't work for wide receivers.  It's worth giving this some thought.

Because of the way that data slowly becomes available, I will continue to modify and adjust some of these results as new information becomes available.


Kevin White, WR, West Virginia  Ht: 6' 2.5"  Wt: 215
40 Time: 4.35  Kangaroo Score: 0.456  Agility Score: 0.267
It seems pretty obvious that White will be gone long before Team Kangaroo would ever need to seriously contemplate selecting him.  I'm not sure that this really bothers me.  I think it's going to be a common theme this year, for me to say that a "player is nice, but we're not necessarily willing to pay the price".  Of all the different athletic traits that a wide receiver can possess, raw speed probably interests me the least.  I generally prefer explosiveness/power or exceptional agility, since I figure that will get a player open more frequently than simply trying to outrun his opponent.  Now, Kevin White doesn't do badly in those areas, but he isn't exactly an unusual prospect either.  He struck us as a fairly tough and dependable wide receiver, though he often seems to play more like a running back.  It was his effort after the catch which seemed like his strongest attribute.  I am obligated (by our Dark Lord Hard Drive) to say that he will probably become a respectable receiver, but I don't know if I really believe that his ceiling is high enough to merit the top 10 pick he is supposedly going to be.

Amari Cooper, WR, Alabama  Ht: 6' 0.75"  Wt: 209
40 Time: 4.42  Kangaroo Score: -0.200  Agility Score: 1.349
I seem to run across a lot of people who compare Amari Cooper to A.J. Green.  To some extent, I get this, since neither player really has amazing lower body power, but I'm still not sure if this is a great comparison.  Really, I find it hard to come up with someone who is in quite the same athletic mold as Cooper.  In some ways, he actually compares better to players like Odell Beckham or Cecil Shorts, who although they are somewhat smaller, both possess a similar sort of rare agility, and just average lower body power..  While Cooper probably isn't as explosive as Beckham, his 10" mitts appear to be more dependable than those of Shorts.  Among the somewhat larger receivers, I really can't find a player who possesses similar athletic traits, as well as the sort of statistical production that Cooper brings to the table.  This both worries me, and fascinates me.  This is why running Cooper through the computer at his pro day weight of 209 pounds matters, as it allows him to be judged against the Small receivers.  Last year, we discussed how Jordan Matthews was sort of like a small receiver in a big receivers body, and Cooper seems like a much more extreme example of the same idea.  While I have no doubt that Cooper's agility can help him get separation from some of the league's average corners, I do have to wonder what will happen when people try to jam him.  For some reason, his college opponents almost always gave him a fairly clean release which seems insanely stupid, at least in retrospect.  Regardless of all that nitpicking, yes, I like Amari Cooper, but I do have some doubts about whether he is the receiver that some people present him as.

DeVante Parker, WR, Louisville  Ht: 6' 2.5"  Wt: 209
40 Time: 4.45  Kangaroo Score:  0.422  Agility Score: ?
Just to be clear, Parker's Stat Score would be significantly higher if we adjusted it for the games he missed due to injury.  It just wasn't necessary to do this, as he met our marks despite that handicap.  As far as his athletic ability is concerned, he seems like a nice all around athlete, though he didn't really excel in any particular area.  He has slightly above average power, but not so much that I would view him as a real threat to abuse anyone.  His speed and quickness are good.  We can only speculate about what his Agility Score would be, though I tend to place much less weight on this for larger receivers.  He has solid hands, and is quite good at going up for the ball, but I wouldn't say that he creates a ton of separation, or has unusual explosiveness.  While we are obviously missing some data, and he only played 6 games in his final season, there do seem to be some interesting reasons to suspect that Parker might have just been starting to emerge as one of the more interesting wide receivers in this draft class.  In those 6 games, there was only one game in which he was responsible for less than 31% of his team's total offense, which is astounding.  Or, if you want to think about in terms of his share of the team's receiving yards, he never dipped below 36% in any single game.  In total, he wound up with 33.7% of his team's total offense, and 51.1% of the team's receiving yards during this period, which are truly ridiculous results.  While his results in prior seasons were significantly less exceptional, it's entirely possible that Parker was just starting to hit his stride.  Without his agility results, we might project that his upside could be similar to what we see with DeAndre Hopkins, while his downside might be similar to Michael Jenkins.  We probably lean more towards the former, rather than the latter of these two outcomes.  Where Parker winds up playing will undoubtedly have a huge influence over his eventual production, but in the end we find it hard to imagine that he won't become a good number 2 receiver, at the very least.  He strikes me as one of the more interesting and enigmatic wide receiver prospects, at least among the ones projected to be taken in the 1st round.

Jaelen Strong, WR, Arizona St.  Ht: 6' 2.3"  Wt: 217
40 Time: 4.44  Kangaroo Score:  1.606  Agility Score: -0.915
Jaelen Strong might end up being an interesting test case for how much agility matters for a big powerful receiver.  Normally, we don't worry about this too much, and just look to see if a player's strengths outweigh their potential weaknesses.  With Strong, we really have to wonder if having a cutoff for certain results might make more sense.  The interesting thing about his agility results is the somewhat lopsided nature of his scores.  In the short shuttle, he produced a result that was respectably average, and 0.176 standard deviations above average.  In the 3-cone drill, which we normally associate with upper body flexibility, Strong's result was an abysmal -2.008 standard deviations below average.  It's very peculiar.  Was it an anomaly, or is it something to be concerned with?  While his overall results bear some similarity to a player like Dez Bryant, Dez's career is a bit of an outlier when it comes to the upside potential of large receivers with horrific agility results.  Another possible comparison, and perhaps a more likely outcome, is that of Jonathan Badlwin.  Baldwin actually wasn't quite as stiff as Strong, but is still rather similar, in a general sort of way.  Also, while we often hear people describing Strong's hands as being exceptionally reliable, his somewhat small 9" mitts only struck me as being a bit average.  The most disturbing thing we saw with Strong, was probably the game against Oregon State, where he faced off against the 5'10" cornerback Steven Nelson.  Strong seemed to have a surprisingly difficult time dealing with somebody he really should have been able to step on like a bug.  The whole reason we lust after big powerful receivers, is that we expect them to fling players like this out of their way, yet Strong didn't appear terribly inclined to do so, which somewhat negates his best selling point.  While we think Strong has some jump ball potential, and can sometimes be dangerous after the catch, we have a hard time imagining him becoming the terror we might be hoping for.  Instead, we suspect he might just become a fairly average receiver, with some red zone potential.  The main reasons we don't want to entirely write him off, is that he is still one of the younger receivers in this class, and if he could learn to direct his power towards violence, he might still turn out to be something interesting.

Nelson Agholar, WR, USC.  Ht:  6'   Wt: 198
40 Time: 4.42  Kangaroo Score:  -0.102  Agility Score: -0.223
In many ways, the computer views Agholar as a slightly faster, but potentially less nimble, version of his former teammate Marqise Lee, for whom we also had somewhat modest expectations.  The main thing Agholar has going for him is his speed, where his 2nd Gear Score of 0.17 suggests that his deep speed is significantly more impressive than his already very good 40 time might suggest.  The way he accelerates from the 10 yard split, to the 20 yard split, and finally to the 40 yard mark, almost qualifies him for our Midget class of speedy receivers, where you find people like DeSean Jackson and T.Y. Hilton, but he doesn't quite fit there.  Most Midget type receivers tend to be incredibly small and lightly built players (hence the politically incorrect name for them), so it's fairly odd that Agholar was even able to come close to this group when it came to how he accelerates.  Personally, we thought Agholar was a fairly respectable receiver, even if he isn't quite as nimble as we would like him to be, and he probably has some real value as a deep threat and kick returner.  We also might even commit ourselves to saying that we somewhat prefer him to Marqise Lee.  Despite that, we don't tend to place a lot of value on small speedy receivers, so even at his generally projected cost of a 2nd round pick, I'm not sure if we would pursue him.

Breshad Perriman, WR, UCF.  Ht: 6' 2"  Wt: 212
40 Time: 4.27  Kangaroo Score:  0.636  Agility Score: ?
Do you like Kevin White, but think you need someone much faster and possibly less dependable?  Honestly, I don't think his hands are nearly as bad as some people say, but he can be a bit erratic and unpredictable about dropping the ball.  While his Kangaroo Score isn't much more impressive than many of the other top rated receivers, his score from the broad jump produced a Kangaroo Score that was 0.962 standard deviations above average, and suggests slightly more promising potential than some of these other players.  In the end, I have to admit that I think he has legitimate number 1 wide receiver potential, but he also might have an equally good chance of being an enormous disappointment.  When you consider how much of his production came against rather mediocre competition, how many games he seemed to disappear in, and the possibility that he might be a bit of a dim bulb, you really would need balls of steel to select him with as high of a pick as some team is probably going to use.  It seems safer just to stand back, and let some other team take the gamble on this one.


Tre McBride, WR, William & Mary  Ht: 6' 0.25"  Wt: 210
40 Time: 4.41  Kangaroo Score:  0.595  Agility Score: 0.398
This is where we come to what the computer thinks might be the sweet spot in the draft.  Do we have some concerns with the idea of drafting an FCS wide receiver who has never surpassed the 900 receiving yards mark even once in the past three years?  Sure we do.  At the same time, if McBride continues to be viewed as just a 3rd round prospect, his potential value aligns with the cost of acquiring him much better than it does with some of the more highly touted prospects.  While his Agility Score isn't remarkable, it is somewhat weighed down by his very average 3-cone drill, but his short shuttle result was 0.956 standard deviations above average.  As far as statistical production, things become a bit murkier.  On the surface, his stat sheet isn't as flashy as many of these other players.  Still, within the context of his team's offense, he carried a respectable share of his team's load, and did so consistently for three years.  When his team faced more challenging competition, like Virginia Tech, West Virginia, or Maryland, it didn't appear to slow McBride down in the least, as he continued to successfully produce positive results.  Based on what we have seen of him, McBride appears to be a very competent player, with above average hands, and from a purely subjective standpoint we rather enjoyed watching him play.  If you watch McBride play, and then compare him to some of the more highly rated prospect, it's hard to say that he isn't as impressive as at least half of them.  Maybe he will become a star, maybe he won't.  Maybe he'll just become a good player.  Either way, I would say that McBride could very easily end up being at least 80% of the player that some of the 1st rounders are, for about half the price.  We would start to consider McBride in the area of the 3rd round.

DeAndre Carter, WR, Sacremento St.  Ht: 5' 8.5"  Wt: 192
40 Time: 4.44  Kangaroo Score:  -0.075  Agility Score:  2.194
Small speedy receivers with some degree of shiftiness aren't exactly in short supply.  There are tons of them in this draft, just like every year, and each one has his fair share of supporters.  You have Tyler Lockett, Kenny Bell, Devin Smith, Rashad Greene, Nelson Agholar, Stefon Diggs, Phillip Dorsett, etc.. Each of these players has his own list of pros and cons.  Some were highly productive players in college.  Some are highly gifted athletes.  Still, there are very few who checked off both of these boxes.  While we have our own subjective opinions and preferences regarding these players, and wouldn't be surprised if one or two of them end up performing quite well in the NFL, we suspect that the majority of them will end up becoming disappointments.  Even among the ones who do succeed, you also have to consider the potentially limited payoff that these sorts of receivers tend to offer.  So, yes, while somebody will end up being correct in their fanatical support for one of these players, the odds still aren't terribly favorable.  With DeAndre Carter, on the other hand, the computer feels a bit more optimistic.  Athletically, he passes through our filters quite comfortably.  Despite his smaller size, he surprisingly appears to have at least average lower body power.  He also possesses good, but not necessarily terrifying speed.  His 10 yard split of 1.45 seconds, and 2nd Gear Score of 0.01, suggest he is probably quicker than he is fast, though in now way are we saying that he is slow.  Max Mulitz and I have sort of discussed the possibility that Carter might be more of an Edelman/Welker type of receiver, rather than a T.Y. Hilton.  Perhaps more importantly, Carter also possesses excellent agility, which should not only assist him in getting open, but also help him to avoid get beaten to a pulp.  When it comes to his statistical production, the computer also gives him high marks, even if he competed at a lower level of competition, because he did appear to dominate his opponents quite convincingly.  Considering that the cost of acquiring him will probably be no more than a 6th round pick, and he may not get drafted at all, there is really very little risk involved here.

Jordan Taylor, WR, Rice  Ht: 6' 4.5"  Wt: 209
40 Time: 4.52  Kangaroo Score:  0.317  Agility Score: -0.302
Like a couple of other players on this list, Taylor just sneaks past our filters, without really excelling in any one area.  While there's nothing shocking about Taylor when examining his athletic traits, there is something we find a bit worrisome.  His BMI results are -1.342 standard deviations below average, which puts him in a class of players where we really start to worry about their risk of injury.  Somebody might want to start feeding this guy some cheeseburgers.  Still, we're not his parents, and his physical welfare isn't going to keep us up at night.  While we wouldn't say that Taylor is an exceptional prospect, or somebody that we would seriously pursue, we do think he could be an interesting red zone threat because of his height, and he does appear to have some rather exceptional and reliable hands that could serve him well in this role.

Geremy Davis, WR, Connecticut  Ht: 6' 2.3"  Wt: 216
40 Time: 4.48*  Kangaroo Score:  0.720  Agility Score:  0.272
What should you do if you like Tre McBride, but feel like being a cheapskate?  Well, you could set your sights on Geremy Davis.  The two receivers really have a lot in common.  They're both somewhat underrated and comparable athletes.  They both played in rather terrible offenses, with horrible quarterbacks, which probably reduced their statistical production.  They also both seem to have rather reliable and consistent hands.  Unfortunately, Davis doesn't seem to be as fast or explosive as McBride, and he is also a full year older.  We probably wouldn't expect Davis to become a terrifying number one receiver, but we wouldn't be surprised in the least if he becomes a solid and respectable secondary target.  We currently seem to see people projecting that Davis will only be a 7th round to UDFA type of prospect, but we think Davis could be an interesting target, maybe starting somewhere around the 5th or 6th round.

Now, this is the point where the computer starts spitting out names of players for whom we have significantly less confidence.  So, bear that in mind, as you continue reading.

Devante Davis, WR, UNLV  Ht: 6' 2.75"  Wt: 220
40 Time: 4.57  Kangaroo Score:  0.577*  Agility Score: -0.471
While his Stat Score appears to be very unimpressive, it starts to look much better when we adjust things to account for the games he missed due to injury.  Still, he manages to get past our minimal requirements even without this adjustment, so we'll ignore this.  While his Kangaroo Score suggests that he has somewhat above average lower body power, his result is a bit less impressive than you would expect for a player of his size.  His agility results are a bit below average, but not unusual for a bigger bodied receiver.  When it comes to speed, his 2nd Gear Score of 0.02 suggests that his fairly pedestrian 40 time is an accurate gauge of his deep speed, and that he probably isn't a significant deep threat.  Overall, he seems like a fairly commonplace possession receiver.  His hands generally appear to be reliable, and we certainly don't think he is a bad player, but in the end we probably wouldn't feel terribly interested in spending a draft pick on him.

Deontay Greenberry, WR, Houston  Ht: 6' 1"  Wt: 211
40 Time: 4.52  Kangaroo Score:  0.044  Agility Score: -1.046
We felt very tempted to cut this player from our list.  Once again, you can see how the computer largely disregards agility for Big receivers.  Unfortunately, Greenberry also lacks the sort of lower body power and explosiveness that we are normally looking for in these types of prospects.  It's really a bit of a mystery to us how he was so productive in college, though playing in a spread offense against fairly mediocre opponents probably helped quite a bit.  He struck us as wildly inconsistent, making a spectacular catch one moment, and then disappearing for long stretches, or simply dropping a pass he should have caught.  If it wasn't for his productive 2013 season, we probably wouldn't be paying attention to him at all, and even in that year his production was just good, and not really amazing.

Da'Ron Brown, WR, Northern Illinois  Ht: 6'  Wt: 205
40 Time: 4.54  Kangaroo Score:  0.134  Agility Score:  0.078
Because of where he falls when it comes to weight, Brown could have been treated as either a Big or a Small receiver.  Unfortunately, his statistical production didn't pass the more difficult filters of the Small receiver group.  As a Big receiver, he faces a different sort of problem, which is that he appears to lack anything more than just average athletic traits, especially when it comes to his lower body power.  He kind of squeaks by, despite falling somewhere in between our mold for either a Big receiver or a Small one.  Still, in the little we have seen of him, he actually appears to be a surprisingly respectable and reliable target.  Considering his lower level of competition, and shortage of exceptional traits that we crave, we probably wouldn't pursue Brown in the draft, but that's probably not a huge problem, since most people seem to expect him to go undrafted.  That he will be 24 years old in September, also sort of weighs his stock down a fair bit.  Despite that, as an UDFA we could definitely have some interest in DaRon Brown.

R.J. Harris, WR, New Hampshire  Ht: 6'  Wt: 200
40 Time: 4.51  Kangaroo Score:  0.206  Agility Score:  -0.706
Harris kind of sneaks through the cracks, on some odd technicalities.  Because of his average size, you would think he would be compared to smaller receivers, but he doesn't pass the computer's filter here because of his low agility (though there were some wild inconsistencies with his results here) and mediocre speed.  Oddly, the computer finds him to be a more interesting, but not thrilling prospect, as a Big receiver.  His speed is adequate for that group, and he does have some explosiveness and average power.  If he weighed just one pound less, we wouldn't even be discussing him.  Harris has squeezed through a weird loophole.  While his level of competition is an obvious concern, he did perform at a fairly dominant level, and appeared to have rather good hands.  Still, I don't really see the sort of exceptional athletic traits that are likely to let him get much separation in the NFL, so I would probably ignore him.

Tyrell Williams, WR, Western Oregon  Ht: 6'3.5"  Wt: 204
40 Time: 4.43  Kangaroo Score:  0.701  Agility Score:  0.602
First of all, don't confuse him with Tyler Williams, the wide receiver from Akron.  Williams is just somebody we view as a bit of a lottery ticket type of player.  Athletically, he is a pretty interesting specimen, with fairly impressive speed, power and agility.  His main physical drawback is his low BMI result (-1.366 standard deviations below average), which puts him into a group of players where injury becomes a much greater concern.  This is another candidate for the all cheeseburger diet plan.  As for his production, well, he technically hits our marks, but it's a bit more complicated in his case.  First of all, he was playing against a much lower level of competition, so we really would have preferred to see him dominate his opponents a bit more than he did.  He was also operating out of a spread offense, that typically allowed him some ridiculous opportunities to just blow past people.  These are factors for which the computer doesn't make adjustments.  We would also say that his hands would probably be described as 'adequate' at best, which might explain why he wasn't a more dominant college player.  We just find him to be mildly interesting as a potential UDFA.


One of the frustrating issues that we run into, is that there are occasionally players who we really like, that the computer simply won't allow us to pick.  This is highly annoying, but in the end we think sticking to a rigid system should work out over the long run.

One example of this sort of restriction is with the Tyler Lockett, from Kansas State.  Here we have a highly entertaining and productive player, that we actually want to draft, but the computer says that we aren't allowed to.  Lockett has respectable speed, good agility, and was highly productive, all of which is very promising.  The problem comes with his lack of mass, since he is only 182 pounds.  When a player is that light, the computer starts to become very demanding of a prospect to demonstrate truly remarkable speed and agility, to compensate for their potential lack of power.  While Lockett's overall results were good, they were just a tad short of where they needed to be in order for us to be allowed to select him.  The computer was also a bit disturbed by Lockett's rather small 8.375" hands.  I really wouldn't be surprised if he ends up being one of the players who exceeds the computer's expectations.

Max Mulitz would probably kill me if I also didn't make some mention of his adopted son Bud Sasser, from Missouri.  Athletically, Sasser passes all of our filters to qualify as a rather interesting Big receiver.  The problem is that Sasser just didn't produce enough prior to 2014 to qualify when it came to his Stat Score, though he didn't miss the mark by much.  It's entirely possible that is the result of a failing on the part of his coaches, and they just didn't recognize his talent.  It's also possible that an older and more physically mature Sasser was just beating up on younger less fully developed opponents in his final year in college.  It's hard to say.  The interesting thing about Sasser is that the computer does think there is a potentially good argument that he might be a better prospect than his former teammate the troubled Dorial Green-Beckham, who is likely to be selected in the 2nd round.  Considering the possibility that Sasser will probably only be a late round pick, he could be an interesting player to pick up.

Last, but not least, we have Cameron Meredith, from Illinois State.  Athletically, he might be one of the more interesting prospects on this list, and almost everything we would want to see in a 6'3" and 207 pound receiver.  He has perfectly good speed, with a 40 time of 4.49 seconds.  He has some fairly good power, with a 0.775 Kangaroo Score.  He also has pretty good agility, with a result of 0.853.  The problem is that his statistical production just doesn't meet our standards, though this might have something to do with the fact that he is a quarterback who was converted to the wide receiver position just 2 seasons ago.  Regardless, in the little we were able to see of him, we actually thought he looked surprisingly good, and made some rather impressive plays.  It seems unlikely that anyone is going to draft him, but he really might be one of our favorite UDFA prospects



Monday, April 6, 2015

Kangaroo Court: The 2015 Running Backs

Well, just like last year, we are again forced to discuss my least favorite topic, the running back prospects.  Now I'll admit, this year's crop of soylent is probably a bit above average, but I'm still not sure how much I really care.  Just give me a decent offensive line, and Charles De Mar as my team's coach, and I'm sure things will work out just fine, regardless of who is carrying the ball.






I'm not really sure if there is anything left to say about running backs..

So, instead, I thought we would discuss the 2003 cinematic masterpiece The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen .  It's a brilliant and often misunderstood little gem, which revolves around some of fiction's most famous and beloved characters.  The story has Twain's Tom Sawyer, Verne's Captain Nemo, Haggard's Allan Quatermain, Wells' invisible man, Stoker's vampire, Wilde's Dorian Gray and Stevenson's Dr. Jekyll, all aligned together to confront a sinister plot by Doyle's Dr. Moriarty.  Let's consider what some of the critics had to say about it. 

This film is odd, loud, unintentionally funny and quite awful. - Richard Roeper

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen just plain reeks. - Stephen Hunter

(The movie) plunges into inexplicable motivations, causes without effects, effects without causes, and general lunacy. - Roger Ebert

Okey-dokey, so perhaps its stunning genius wasn't broadly recognized or appreciated at the time of its release.  Not all of the great works get recognized early in their existence, and sometimes we need a little while to catch up with the minds of greater men and their creations.  It also doesn't help that people seem to think that this movie was intended to be good, which I have some very strong doubts about.  If its mission was intentionally directed towards causing a very different reaction in its audience, which we will argue that it might have achieved, wouldn't we have to reconsider whether the film was a success and a genuine work of art?  Whether it hit its intended target, has to matter as much as whether we actually like what target it chose to aim for, right?

Let's start from the beginning here.  Before its arguably horrible/brilliant celluloid manifestation, there was a comic book of the same name, written by Alan Moore.  Now, while people will say that you shouldn't judge a book by its cover, would you say that Alan Moore looks like a genius or a lunatic?



Clearly, this is a man who has got it together.  If his dapper appearance doesn't convince you that he's a brilliant and sophisticated individual, maybe there's something else that will persuade you.  He's English.  Yup, he has a fancy accent, which typically means that he can project an air of intellectual superiority, and make anything he says sound much smarter.  Al-u-minium.  So, when he crafted a story that borrowed some of the most famous characters of deceased writers, and put them all together in one adventure, there must have been some sound reasoning for it, correct?

Well, if we put ourselves into the mind of an artist, what sort of issues do you think might matter to them, that might not matter to an ordinary Joe?  Now, when you look at Alan Moore, does he strike you as someone who can be trusted with children?  No, probably not.  Despite the generally open-minded generosity of the fairer sex, you have to suspect that Moore is likely going to be the end of a genetic line, and so his emotional investment in offspring continuing his legacy is doubtful.  So, if we believe that every man wants to leave something behind for which he will be remembered, what else could he be concerned with other than his work?

Now if a man is highly committed to his daily labor, what might weigh on his soul, and cause him to sleep a bit restlessly?  One of the obvious problems with being a creative individual, is sending your handiwork out into the world, where you have no idea how it will be received.  Unlike a sculptor working in tough and unyielding stone, a man who works with paper and ink, is particularly vulnerable to the unpredictable vagaries of the lunatic masses.  Even worse, for a writer, copyright law only protects his creation for a mere 70 years after his death, at which point it enters the dreaded public domain, and any bumbling fool can meddle with and remix his thoughts.  Basically, every work of genius eventually devolves into Twilight fan fiction, given a long enough period of time.

Oddly, this dreaded meddling and cheapening of an artist's legacy, is very similar to what we see happening in The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen.  Is this just a coincidence?  I have to wonder, was this film actually created to horrify its audience through the banality of unoriginal thought, so as to encourage us to end this very sort of inept fumbling with the works of greater artists, and eliminate the concept of the public domain altogether?  The film certainly makes a strong argument for this case, even if its real message is often misunderstood and concealed in buffoonery.  Perhaps, by being willing to be mistaken for fools, and comically inept, the creators of this movie are striking a bold and powerful blow for artists everywhere.  They are practically serving themselves up as martyrs for a much greater cause, with likely very little reason to think that their true motives will be understood.  The director, Stephen Norrington, would watch his career wither and die after this film's release, and hasn't been allowed to direct or have any significant participation in a single film since this crowning 2003 achievement.  I have to suspect this was all a clear and selfless act of heroism and personal sacrifice, and yet like Peter, we all denied him at least three times before the Academy Awards.

So, yes, unless someone would like to argue to the contrary, that this movie was actually intended to be good, I will just be sitting here awaiting my MacArthur Genius Grant, along with the inevitable lifetime achievement Oscar that this film clearly deserves for its contribution to artists everywhere.

Now, let's move on to this year's crop of scrambling and overrated commodities at the running back position.

I've already mentioned my peculiar views on running backs and their athletic abilities, so I'll just skip ahead a bit here.  The player's Kangaroo Score (our measure of lower body power) and Agility Score (based on their short shuttle and 3-cone times) will be given in the form of how many standard deviations above, or below average, that the player happens to be compared to his peers at the same position.  I'll also include the player's 2nd Gear Score, and Speed Score.  Personally, I have some issues with using the Speed Score, but a fair number of people are familiar with it, so I figured I would toss it in there.  I should also mention that I use the unofficial 40 times, rather than the magically altered official times of the NFL, since I prefer to look at the results in relation to a player's 10-yard split.



This list will continue to be updated, as new data and prospects come to my attention.  I won't list everyone here, but instead will just mention the players that I feel are interesting for one reason or another. Last Updated: 4/20/2015



Todd Gurley, RB, Georgia  Ht: 6' 0.5"  Wt: 222
40 Time: ?   2nd Gear: ?   Speed Score: ?   Kangaroo Score: ?  Agility Score: ?
Because of his torn ACL, it seems unlikely that we are going to get the sort of data that we prefer to have.  That leaves us in the unpleasant position of having to weigh Gurley based solely off of his statistical production, and our worthless subjective opinion.  So, here we go.  Gurley's eyes seem to gaze directly into your soul.  He has the sort of strong arms, that can hold you tight and make you feel safe and secure.  His feet have ten toes, so that you can play a full round of "this little piggy".  Eh, I'm assuming that's how these things work when scouts try to size things up by eye, right?  Actually, I think Gurley probably is just about the most exciting running back in this draft, which only makes me more disappointed that we don't have measurable data for him.  He appeared to be a fast and powerful runner, who was creative and had a fair amount of ability to escape tackles.  We also like that he has shown some history of being a receiving option.  One nagging concern, is that when Gurley went down with his injury, Nick Chubb (awesome name) appeared to carry the load with hardly a slip in the team's production, or yards per carry.  Despite that, yes, we do think Gurley is probably at least a step ahead of this year's other running back prospects.  The real question for us is, do we care?  Do you really need a top tier running back, so much that you are willing to spend a 1st round pick on one?  This kind of reminds me of a commercial that General Motors used to run for some of their trucks.  Their slogan was "It's not more than you need. It's just more than you're used to".  Just give that statement a moment's thought, and tell me whether you find that message to be as horrific and disturbing as I do.  So, to turn that line around, Gurley will probably offer more than you're used to from your team's running back, but he might also be more than you need.

Melvin Gordon, RB, Wisconsin  Ht: 6' 0.5"  Wt: 215
40 Time: 4.52  2nd Gear: 0.10  Speed Score: 103.0   Kangaroo Score: 0.492  Agility Score: 0.652
Gordon's results were all over the map, which potentially makes his Agility and Kangaroo Scores a bit misleading.  His broad jump would have resulted in a score of 0.934, but gets weighed down by his vertical jump.  Still, there are promising signs of power.  Gordon's short shuttle was 1.396 standard deviations above average, but he followed that up with a very average 3-cone drill.  His 2nd Gear Score of 0.10, also suggests that his deep speed is probably a bit better than his 40 time might suggest.  Okay, so he has some impressive athletic ability buried in there, but the real concern is that historically everybody who carries the ball at Wisconsin ends up doing well.  I have to admit though, Gordon struck me as a rather respectable runner, even if we do have some worries about how he was rarely used as a receiving option.  I just have to wonder why anyone would ever draft a running back anywhere near the 1st round.  It's just one of those questionable life decisions, like getting married right out of high school, that I can't understand.  Even if you marry a supermodel (which we'll say is Adrian Peterson in this analogy) don't you think you're going to regret that you didn't sow your wild oats with a bunch of cheap 4th round picks?

Jay Ajayi, RB, Boise State  Ht: 5' 11.5"  Wt: 221
40 Time: 4.57  2nd Gear: 0.02  Speed Score: 101.3  Kangaroo Score: 1.105  Agility Score: 0.407
As far as I can tell, Ajayi seems to do almost everything a running back is asked to do fairly well.  For the most part, he struck me as a respectably useful and versatile player.  My only concern with his athleticism had to do his speed, which was just a bit marginal.  Unlike Melvin Gordon, who also had a fairly bland 40 time, Ajayi's 2nd Gear Score suggests a lesser likelihood that his deep speed is being underestimated.  While Ajayi's production was fairly respectable, even if his average yards per carry was somewhat unexceptional,  the teams he faced weren't overly impressive.  Really, I suspect it is primarily his productivity as a receiver that is boosting his value in most people's eyes.  As far as concerns go, well, he has fumbled the ball more than you might like.  He was also arrested for stealing a pair of sweatpants from Walmart, back in 2011.  Okay, that's probably where I draw the line.  He clearly lacks vision, which is supposedly important for a running back.  If you are going to go down for a crime, you have to at least head for the high end electronics.  I don't see him as a particularly exceptional prospect, but he does seem like a reasonably competent and versatile one.

Ameer Abdullah, RB, Nebraska  Ht: 5' 8.5"  Wt: 205
40 Time: 4.61  2nd Gear: 0.00  Speed Score: 88.8  Kangaroo Score: 1.142  Agility Score: 1.655
We're generally not big fans of these pint sized running backs, and we have some doubt about whether Abdullah can ever become a significant blocker, but he does seem to have some interesting tools to work with.  While his 40 time at the combine was a rather disappointing result, we think we have to also take a look at his pro day numbers.  At Nebraska, he seemed to get a much better start to his run, with a 10 yard split of 1.48 seconds, and finished his run with a respectably average result of 4.55 seconds.  Still, that would put his 2nd Gear Score at -0.07, which suggests that he is more quick than fast.  His statistical production was excellent, even though he was clearly the focus of his team's offense, and his surrounding talent probably wasn't exceptional.  In the end though we couldn't help but feel like he bore a bit of a resemblance to David Wilson.  There's just something very boring about watching him play.  Despite his agility, he was less of a receiving threat than we would have expected, though this might have something to do with his small 8.625" hands.  Those tiny mitts might also explain his issues with fumbling the ball.  While we wouldn't want to bet against a guy like this, we can't say he ever made us say 'Wow!'.

Duke Johnson, RB, Miami  Ht: 5' 9"  Wt: 207
40 Time: 4.54  2nd Gear: 0.06  Speed Score: 97.4  Kangaroo Score: -0.209  Agility Score: 0.730
I think it is safe to say that Johnson is not going to be a bruising between the tackle runner, based on his slightly below average Kangaroo Score.  For similar reasons, it would also appear to be unlikely that he will ever amount to very much as a blocker.  Fortunately, the picture for Johnson improves somewhat when we look at his Agility Score.  As an outside the tackles runner, his average timed speed would be a bit of a concern for us, though it seems to be his best option.  Really, his most noticeably above average trait seems to be his ability as a receiver.  Overall, he struck us as a very unimpressive player, and someone who was ridiculously easy to tackle.  If a team is really going to select Johnson in the 2nd or 3rd round, as some have suggested, we would tend to suspect that they will end up feeling a bit disappointed with the returns from this investment

Tevin Coleman, RB, Indiana  Ht: 5' 11"  Wt: 206
40 Time: ?  2nd Gear: ?   Speed Score: ?   Kangaroo Score: ?  Agility Score: ?
On a pleasant sunny 70 degree day, with a wide open path ahead of him, and facing an opposing team made up of drunk and limping Quakers, Tevin Coleman can break some pretty long runs.  Outside of those conditions, I don't find him nearly as interesting as his ridiculous yards per carry stats would suggest.  If you farted in his general direction, I suspect it would be enough to knock him down.

David Johnson, RB, Northern Iowa  Ht: 6' 0.5"  Wt: 224
40 Time: 4.50  2nd Gear: 0.08  Speed Score: 109.2  Kangaroo Score: 1.976  Agility Score: 0.501
Despite his very impressive lower body power, he only struck me as a mildly interesting runner.  The peculiar thing with Johnson was that he actually looked  liked a reasonable blocker, and really surprised me with how good he looked as receiver.  It might be insane, but I really had to wonder if he might be an interesting player to turn into a big bodied wide receiver.  Because of the lower level of competition that he faced, and the fact that he will already be turning 24 in December, I can't see taking him before the 4th round.  I wouldn't bet on him becoming a star, but as a number 2 running back with some upside, he could be a worthwhile prospect.

T.J. Yeldon, RB, Alabama  Ht: 6' 1.25"  Wt: 226
40 Time: 4.61  2nd Gear: 0.02  Speed Score: 100.0  Kangaroo Score: 0.712  Agility Score: -0.213
If we take the results of his pro day seriously, then we would have to consider his reported 4.52 second 40 time.  Either way, his 2nd Gear Score hardly budges at all, and doesn't suggest that his deep speed is much more than just average at best.  When you take that, in combination with his somewhat above average power, and arguably average agility, we'd say he is just a reasonably respectable athlete.  The problem is that we don't trust players from Alabama.  While his statistical production was fairly good, it wasn't anything that separates him from every other running back who floats though Alabama.  He showed no significant contribution as a receiver, and basically split carries with Derrick Henry in 2014, who's average YPC was better than Yeldon's.  While Yeldon had games where we thought he looked like a fairly good prospect, he also had just as many games where he seemed to accomplish very little.  While we wouldn't be amazed if Yeldon has a decent career, we also wouldn't bet against him being enshrined in the museum of former Alabama players who did nothing upon entering the NFL.  Coming from a team like Alabama, we would really require some stronger signs of exceptional ability in order to consider spending draft pick.

David Cobb, RB, Minnesota  Ht: 6' 0.5"  Wt: 222
40 Time: 4.81  2nd Gear: ?  Speed Score: 85.56  Kangaroo Score: 1.479  Agility Score: ?
We have to assume that his 40 time at the combine was some sort of comical error, because he is clearly faster than that.  Either way, he appears to be a perfectly reasonable power back, and though we can't judge his agility, he didn't strike us as a stiff.  While he was rarely thrown to, he didn't look unnatural as a receiver.  The biggest concern with Cobb is probably his unfortunate number of fumbles.  Still, we probably enjoyed watching Cobb more than Jay Ajayi of Ameer Abdullah.  If he was available in the 4th round we'd probably give him some minor consideration.

Zach Zenner, RB, South Dakota St.  Ht: 5' 11.5"  Wt: 223
40 Time: 4.61  2nd Gear: 0.03  Speed Score: 98.7  Kangaroo Score: 1.504  Agility Score: 0.320
Have you ever seen those commercials, where they show a small child who has been crippled or is missing a limb, and the narrator asks for your donation to help these pathetic creatures live a normal life?  Yeah, it's kind of like that with Zach Zenner.  You see, through no fault of his own, he was born with a terrible and career threatening birth defect.  Because of this, he will most likely never get a chance to be an NFL running back, despite having some impressive athletic traits, and being extremely productive in college  He might get to be a fullback though, because the NFL is extremely predictable in how they handle these sorts of players.  With your help, just $0.25 per day, we can get Zenner the tanning bed he so desperately needs.  Think of the children.

Terrell Watson, RB, Azusa Pacific  Ht: 6' 0.5"  Wt: 239
40 Time: 4.55  2nd Gear: 0.02  Speed Score: 110.2  Kangaroo Score: 1.534  Agility Score: -1.819
When the initial reports of Watson's pro day came out, Reilly and I quickly jumped onto the bandwagon.  His speed, for his size, and power, were quite attractive.  There is also something that is undeniably hilarious about watching a guy like this as he pummels his Division II competition.  I also have to admit that I might be getting suckered a bit by his story of dealing with a learning disability, and his pleasant personality.  That really disturbs me, because it might suggest that I haven't completely purged myself of feelings and humanity.  Then the numbers came out for Watson's short shuttle time and 3-cone drill, and we somewhat fell off the bandwagon, just a little bit.  What these numbers said about his agility was a tad bothersome.  Okay, so there probably isn't a lot of Barry Sanders level elusiveness here.  Still, there is a place in the league for guys who just run their opponents over, and are hard to bring down, and Watson might really fit that role quite nicely.  While his level of competition is a valid concern, the cost of acquiring him should more than compensate for this risk.  If people are going to ignore him, I'd probably be willing to swoop in and take him with a late round pick. 

Corey Grant, RB, Auburn  Ht: 5' 8.75"  Wt: 201
40 Time: 4.28  2nd Gear: 0.29  Speed Score: 119.7  Kangaroo Score: 0.036  Agility Score:  0.714
A 40 time of 4.28 seconds is obviously impressive, though we don't tend to get suckered by speed very easily.  A 40 time of 4.28 seconds, with a 2nd Gear Score of 0.29, is something that makes us take a second look.  Oh yes, that could be some very serious speed we are seeing here.  While his Kangaroo Score only suggests fairly average lower body power, when you factor in his above average agility, it's not hard to guess what sort of running back you are dealing with here.  The odd thing is that he doesn't appear to have been used very much at all in his time at Auburn.  In the end, there doesn't seem to be enough information to fully evaluate Grant or opportunities to watch him play, but at the very least you would think he could be used as a kick returner, and perhaps a bit more.

Dreamius Smith, RB, West Virginia  Ht: 5' 10.5"  Wt: 223
40 Time: 4.48  2nd Gear: 0.11  Speed Score: 110.7  Kangaroo Score: 0.815  Agility Score:  1.054
Players with names like Dreamius are sort of our kryptonite.  If names determined a player's draft status, he would be a 1st rounder.  Now, as far as athletic ability goes, Smith should be a fairly ideal prospect.  On paper, he has size, speed, power and agility.  What he doesn't have is much of a proven history on the field.  In 2013, he backed up Charles Sims, an eventual 3rd round pick.  In 2014, Smith backed up Rushell Shell and Wendell Smallwood, despite having a higher yards per carry than either of them.  So, is there something terribly wrong with him that we are unaware of, or did he just get screwed over by the coaches at West Virginia?  I really have no idea.  While we've only been able to see a small sample of his plays so far, he appeared to be quite capable.  Honestly, we thought he looked just as good as at least half of the guys who are projected to be taken in the 2nd or 3rd round.  Still, it currently appears to be somewhat unlikely that he will be drafted at all.  That makes him very interesting to us.  At the very least, we would view him as a high priority UDFA, but wouldn't rule out the possibility of drafting him just based on his athletic potential.



Monday, March 30, 2015

Kangaroo Court: The 2015 Linebackers

A long time ago, in a galaxy far far away, I worked at a liquor store.  It was a rather wonderful experience, because it made my own my youthful adventures with amateur alcoholism seem rather pathetic and harmless, at least in comparison to the more dedicated lushes I would encounter there.  If the livers of those dedicated sots were still functional, I clearly had little reason to worry.  Being able to make flattering comparisons between myself and more damaged individuals is sort of how I get by in this world.

One of the interesting things about serious drunkards, was in the strange peculiarities of their drinking habits.  You'd think that a large 1.75 liter bottle of liquor would be the most efficient way to get the job done when you were consuming massive quantities on a daily basis, but this was rarely the case.  In fact, the "miniature" bottles, as they are called, are the real sign that you might have a problem (or a solution, depending on your point of view).  It's quite possible that you've never bought one of these tiny bottles, but that's just because you haven't fully committed yourself to a proper and sustained binge.  It's quite likely that you lack the discipline and dedication to pursue a mission of self-destruction, and need to step up your game.

Regardless, the beauty of the "miniature" is that it fits pretty much anywhere.  It's the derringer of the debauchee.  You can toss a few into your pocket.  They can be inconspicuously hidden in desk drawers.  Your average glove compartment can hold quite a nice arsenal of them as well.  They are made for the drunk on the go.  They fuel the man who has things he has to get done, even if he might not remember doing them later. 

Now, let me put this into perspective, just a little bit.  I also made daily alcohol deliveries to some of the residents of nearby nursing homes.  One older and somewhat decrepit gentleman, who so far as I could tell never left his reclining chair, would consume a half-gallon of the cheapest vodka that we were legally allowed to sell, every single day.  Over the course of a week, that works out to about 3.5 gallons of liver candy.  Some people might find that a bit disturbing.  Others might find that to be pretty damned impressive.  All I can say is that after a while, you came to admire this sort of drinker.  We really should have built a shrine to this man.  He was like an Olympian, and his disregard for his own well-being was both glorious and absurd.  There he is, sitting in his nursing home.  His children probably haven't visited him in months.  The clock is winding down, and he figures "Screw it.  I'm getting drunk, and I'm going to stay drunk".  I can respect that...umm...sort of.

When you dealt with Miniature Man, you got a very different vibe.  You knew he was sneaking something on the side.  Somewhere, there must be a wife snooping through his drawers, or a boss who was subtly sniffing his breath.  Miniature Man was still trying to appear functional, even if he was clearly somewhat haggard.  He was trying to keep a secret, even if the burst blood vessels in his nose kept squealing on him.  He just wasn't quite ready to baptize himself in booze, and fully dedicate himself to the cause.  It was a tad depressing, selling those tiny bottles to him, and it felt like you were watching somebody try to commit suicide by repeatedly shooting themselves with a BB gun, when you were perfectly willing to hand them a shotgun.

So, what does any of this have to do with linebackers?  Err....hmmm....gimme a second.  I'm sure I can spin some nonsensical connection here.

I suppose, much like we discussed with last year's list of linebackers,  that we are just expressing our preference for football players who approach the game with a lack of restraint, or concern for their own well-being.  I suspect that you kind of have to throw common sense out the window to truly excel as a linebacker, because anyone with an instinct for self-preservation would probably choose another profession.  Still, there are quite a few players who seem to tiptoe around the field, and that greatly diminishes the benefits of the "bread and circuses" distractions that the Lizard People are trying to provide for us.  Timid play diverts our attention from the spectacle before us, and makes us start to contemplate things like "Is the fluoridation of our tap water really an attempt to drug us, and control our minds?"  These are things we really shouldn't be thinking about, if we know what is good for us, and watching players recklessly assault one another helps to keep our mind at peace.

Sleep....sleeeeeeeeeep........sleeeeeeeeeeeeeeep......You want to buy a Ford F-150.....Coors Light is delicious and refreshing......sleeeeeeeep.......... Vote yes for funding a new $1.5 billion stadium in Los Angeles........sleeeep..........

Since the athletic traits of players in this category are measured against all defensive prospects who are under 275#, this skews their results when it comes to the Kangaroo Score, because they don't have the same mass as some of the larger outside pass rushers in this weight class.  Since the goal is to see how many standard deviations away from an average result that a player is, we have to make some mental adjustments here.  For these (generally) lighter prospects, a Kangaroo Score of -0.800, would be the approximate point at which we would find the 'average' player in this group.  Among these lighter prospects, you typically start to see Pro Bowl and All Pro players reaching a score of -0.400, or better.  Just like the Kangaroo Score, the Agility Score (which comes from the short shuttle and 3-cone drill), will also be given in the form of how many standard deviations away from the  average result that a player is.  While the Kangaroo Scores for these players tend to suffer by comparison to heavier players, these lighter prospects generally make up for this by having an advantage when it comes to how nimble they are.  So, we prefer to see Agility Scores that are at least 1.000 standard deviation above average.   Normally, I would expect a player with a higher Kangaroo Score to be a stronger hitter, and more productive on blitzes, while a player with a high Agility Score will probably be better in coverage.  Still, nothing is set in stone, and individuals do vary in how they perform.

This list will continue to be modified and updated, as new data and prospects come to my attention.  The list won't include every player. but instead, just the ones that I find interesting for one reason or another.  Last Updated: 4/26/2015



Eric Kendricks  ILB, UCLA
40 Time: 4.61    Kangaroo Score: -0.136   Agility Score:  0.777
As far as Kendricks's athletic ability is concerned, things seem to check out rather nicely.  He has perfectly acceptable speed.  His Kangaroo Score is significantly above average for a player in this weight class.  His Agility Score might be a bit lower than we would like, but that seems like the product of an irregularity with the results from his 3-cone drill.  Fortunately, this irregularity favors his short shuttle score, which is 1.236 standard deviations above average, and something we highly value in linebackers.  When it comes to his statistical production, he appears to have been a fairly dominant and consistent force over the course of several years, which we love to see.  In the handful of games we watched, he performed just as well as we would have hoped, based on his data.  He seemed rather versatile, and appeared to do well against the run and in coverage.  We really see no reason to object to him.  Among the players generally projected to be taken near the end of the 1st round, we think he is probably one of the better/safer options, and someone we could have some real interest in.  An added bonus is that he was born on February 29th, so his skills should erode at a quarter of the normal rate for an NFL player.

Shaq Thompson OLB/S, Washington
40 Time: 4.64    Kangaroo Score: -1.270   Agility Score:  1.232
He seems to be everyone's favorite 'jack of all trades, master of none' candidate.  As a linebacker prospect, I have my doubts about whether he has the size or power to avoid getting physically abused.  Honestly, we'd probably rule him out as a linebacker, though our opinion of him as a safety is quite a bit more positive.  That requires comparing his traits to a very different set of athletes, which results in very different scores..

Randy Gregory, OLB, Nebraska
40 Time: 4.64    Kangaroo Score: -0.130   Agility Score:  1.182
&
Eli Harold  OLB, Virginia
40 Time: 4.53    Kangaroo Score:  0.137   Agility Score:  0.856
It's hard to say how Gregory or Harold would do as a LB in a 4-3 or as an ILB in a 3-4, but we just wanted to throw that option out there.  We weren't terribly impressed by either one of them as 3-4 OLB or DE prospects, but their measurable traits suggest that this sort of position switch might be beneficial.  In fact, they would be comparable to some fairly impressive NFL players at this position.  Unfortunately, this requires quite a bit of wild speculation, since what they did in college doesn't really give us a great glimpse of how they would do in this very different sort of role.  It's probably not something I would want to gamble on with a high pick, but if they end up struggling early on in their careers (assuming that they become 3-4 OLBs), a position switch could be interesting.  This possibility sort of makes us think about the similar situation that the Dolphins are in, as they are now contemplating a similar switch with Dion Jordan, whom we also disliked as a pass rushing prospect.

Bernardrick McKinney  OLB, Mississippi St.
40 Time: 4.66    Kangaroo Score:  0.730   Agility Score:  0.282
I have very mixed feelings about McKinney.  On the one hand, his Kangaroo Score suggests significantly above average lower body power and explosiveness.  For a player at his position, I would expect that to translate to being fairly stout against the run, and possibly making him a decent blitzer.  On the other hand, his Agility Score might suggest that he is a bit stiff, and could struggle in coverage.  It's like reading the future in chicken bones.  In the handful of games that I was able to watch, these expectations seemed to be rather accurate, though I also got the impression that he was just a fairly average tackler.  Now, if somebody wanted to use him as a thumping inside linebacker in a 3-4, who you might pull off the field in obvious passing situations, I guess I could see him doing a decent job in that role.  If he is going to be selected in the 2nd round, as many seem to suggest, I just think the value of a player like this might be a bit debatable for that sort of investment.

Stephone Anthony   ILB, Clemson
40 Time: 4.56    Kangaroo Score:  0.162   Agility Score:  1.216
It's hard to criticize Anthony's athletic ability.  He's pretty much an ideal physical specimen.  As far as his actual production goes, he's a bit more peculiar.  Compared to most MLBs, he had a rather high number of eye catching plays (TFLs, FFs, sacks, etc), but a surprisingly low tackle count.  The role that his Clemson teammates had in helping to inflate some of his stats is hard to judge, though it's also impossible to discount.  The defense did appear to be rather talented as a whole.  When we watched him play, we actually thought he looked rather good, though we sometimes questioned the decisions he made.  Compared to Eric Kendricks, Anthony seems like a potentially higher reward type of player, but also a potentially higher risk.  If he continues to be ranked as a 2nd round pick, we'd probably view that as an acceptable price for someone like him.

Hau'oli Kikaha   OLB, Washington
40 Time: 4.93    Kangaroo Score:  -0.462   Agility Score:  0.101
This was a player who we were very curious to learn about, but after his pro day we've lost a lot of interest.  He doesn't seem to quite fit the ideal mold for an outside pass rusher, but he also doesn't seem to be fast enough, or agile enough, to be exciting as a more conventional linebacker.  Since people seem to be projecting that he will be a selection in the 2nd or 3rd round, that would be significantly more costly than what we would consider to be reasonable.

Paul Dawson  ILB, TCU
40 Time: 4.75    Kangaroo Score:  -1.890*   Agility Score:  0.540*
We're not fans of the "He's a football player, not a track star" argument.  Why not say,"I'm not an athlete, but I play one in football games."  In an attempt to be generous, we're listing Dawson's results based on his pro day.  While people may point to a player like Vontaze Burfict, as an example of someone who tested poorly but seems to have done well in the NFL, we view that as a rather large exception to the rules.  Also, similar to Burfict, some people seem to be expressing concerns with Dawson's character.  At least when the Bengal's picked up Burfict as an UDFA, the balance of risk versus reward was strongly tilted in their favor.  They had nothing to lose.  We have to admit that we won't be watching any of Dawson's games, even though we do respect his statistical production, because it would just be a waste of our time.  Even if we thought he looked like a good player, this just isn't the sort of gamble we are looking to pursue.

Kwon Alexander   OLB, LSU
40 Time: 4.55    Kangaroo Score:  -0.792   Agility Score:  0.610
Well, if we can trust Rod Tidwell, then "it's all about the kwon".  So he has that going for him.  Honestly, we have minimal interest in Alexander as a linebacker prospect.  His athletic ability is just on the fringe of what we would consider.  His statistical production is passable, but not very interesting.  Seeing as he frequently seems to be listed as a 3rd round prospect, there is very little that would make us want to pay that price.  On the other hand, his physical traits and smaller size (about 6'0.5" and 227 pounds), do make him a fairly respectable fit for the strong safety position.  Overall, he didn't make much of a positive impression on us as a linebacker.

Denzel Perryman   ILB, Miami
40 Time: 4.78    Kangaroo Score:  -1.319   Agility Score:  ?
We're still waiting for data from Perryman's pro day, so we haven't completely made up our minds about him   Nonetheless, we already have some concerns about his somewhat mediocre speed, and below average lower body power.  It's causing us to lean strongly towards the idea that Perryman should only go to a 4-3 team, with a rather stout defensive line to protect him.  While we liked his statistical production, and thought he generally looked fairly respectable in the games we watched, we currently would have a hard time accepting the 2nd round grade that many people seem to have given to him. 

Ben Heeney   ILB, Kansas
40 Time: 4.59    Kangaroo Score:  -0.975   Agility Score:  2.050 
If you put him in a colander, he would probably come running out the other end.  At least that is the sort of fluidity that the computer feels Heeney has based on his Agility Score.  While we like his athletic ability, we still would have some concerns about his fairly mediocre Kangaroo Score.  This potential lack of power might require that he play behind a fairly solid defensive line.  Despite that concern, we thought he was one of the more enjoyable linebacker prospects that we have watched so far.  In many ways, both in terms of athletic ability on the field play, he reminded us of Paul Worrilow, and no, it's not just because they suffer from the same terrible birth defect.  While both players have exceptional agility, that we would normally associate with coverage linebackers, this doesn't seem to be the real area of strength for either player.  Instead, they both seem to be roving tackling machines, who do better against the run.  We would be rather interested in acquiring Heeney for Team Kangaroo if he is still be available in the 3rd or 4th round.

Jordan Hicks   OLB, Texas
40 Time: 4.68    Kangaroo Score:  0.061   Agility Score:  1.442 
At least on paper, this is a prospect I would normally get excited about.  Hicks has fairly ideal athletic traits for a linebacker.  His statistical production in college, at least in his senior year, also looks rather impressive.  Unfortunately, when we watched him play, the only description that popped into my head was 'bozo'.  That seems to happen a lot with players from Texas.  We also have to consider the fact that Hicks has missed a rather significant amount of playing time due to injuries.  In 2012, he missed time with a hip injury.  In 2013,  it was his achilles tendon.  Somebody clearly doesn't know how to "rub some dirt on it".  When I look around, I seem to see him projected as a mid round pick.  I guess that there are worse prospects, but the 5th or 6th round is about as high as I could see taking him, and even then I wouldn't be thrilled with doing so.

Mike Hull   OLB, Penn State
40 Time: 4.68    Kangaroo Score:  -1.636   Agility Score:  1.038
Well, the numbers would suggest that Hull is a reasonably nimble linebacker, with a possibly serious shortage of power.  As far as I can tell, based on watching him play, he seems to fit that description.  I wouldn't say that he looked bad, because he definitely had his positive moments, but I do think this guy is probably better suited to playing in a 4-3, or at least going to a team with a serious defensive line to protect him.  Even then I suspect I wouldn't want to see him become a starter, though he could be okay for depth.  One other drawback is that he will already be turning 24 in May, and has really only had one college season with significant production.  I probably wouldn't pursue him, but I could understand why someone might take him somewhere late in the draft.

Bryce Hager   ILB, Baylor
40 Time: 4.6    Kangaroo Score:  -0.802   Agility Score:  0.148 
I'm starting to wonder if the defensive players at Baylor have their statistical production inflated, in a similar manner to what we normally see with their offensive players.  Despite a fairly impressive stat sheet, I don't really see much here that would make me interested in pursuing Hager.  There are probably worse prospects than Hager, but I just don't get the sense that he possesses much upside.

Jake Ryan  OLB, Michigan
40 Time: 4.65    Kangaroo Score:  -0.493   Agility Score:  0.668 
Oh, I don't know.  Ryan seems like a fairly respectable and serviceable athlete.  I could even make an argument for boosting his Agility Score a tad, based on some irregularities in his results.  I sometimes questioned his decision making and range, but as a straight ahead hitter, and occasional blitzer, he seemed fairly good.  In what I suspect is a relatively mediocre draft class, I could see him as one of the more interesting late round linebackers, though I probably wouldn't bet on stardom.  People seem to be projecting that he will get selected somewhere around the 5th round, and that sounds about right to me.

Damien Wilson   ILB, Minnesota
40 Time: 4.77    Kangaroo Score:  0.091   Agility Score:  0.476 
In Damien Wilson's case, I have to admit that we are missing a fair amount of data that we would like to have.  We also weren't able to watch him play very much, so we sort of  have to base our hunches off of his numbers.  Athletically, he should be a fairly reasonable prospect.  His speed is a bit pedestrian, but acceptable.  He should have good lower body power and explosiveness.  As far as his agility is concerned, he wasn't amazing, though his short shuttle results were very promising.  He also appears to have been fairly productive in his final college season.  The main reason to be interested in Wilson is that he generally isn't projected to be drafted at all.  So, a team could probably bring him in as an UDFA.  If so, he has enough potential to be interesting, but a team wouldn't be taking any real risks.  That's not a bad situation to be in.



Saturday, March 28, 2015

Cedric Thompson: Shopping For A Wedding Ring

I don't see any likely reason to suspect that my family is going to stumble into great wealth in the near future.  We are a rather humble group, with no exceptional traits that are likely to steer a fortune in our direction.  It seems that we are far more likely to ride someone else's coattails to the easy life.  With that in mind, I'm trying to get my sister to consider marrying Minnesota safety Cedric Thompson, whom I've already heaped some praise upon.  I have to admit that I've grown a bit infatuated with him as a draft prospect, and I'm sure my sister will learn to love him as well.

Thompson seems like a rather ideal prospect for this ploy.  He's currently projected to be no more than a late round draft pick, though it's even possible that he won't be selected at all.  So, he's probably a fairly humble guy, and might be willing to settle for someone like my sister.  I mean, let's face it, she's not going to be attracting any 1st round picks.  We have to aim a bit lower, and catch a guy before he really knows that he can do much better.  With that said, I really see no reason to think that Thompson isn't a superior prospect to someone like Landon Collins, who essentially plays the same position and is generally expected to be taken somewhere at the top of the draft.  My sister would sort of have to play the long game here, possibly waiting for Thompson's second NFL contract, but I'm willing to be patient.

Despite some differences in their physical builds, Thompson generally matches or surpasses Collins in most of the areas that probably matter.  When it comes to speed, Collins ran a 4.53 40 time, compared to Thompson's 4.46 (though some have suggested that his times were significantly better).  Collins' Kangaroo Score (our measure of lower body power), was an impressive 1.650, but despite being a bit smaller Thompson put up an equally impressive 1.605.  Unreliable and superficial speculation about the benefits of a player's size seem to be a possible illusion in this case.   Then we come to the subject of their nimbly-toed gracefulness, where Collins produced a wretched -1.738 Agility Score, compared to Thompson's much improved -0.462 (which is within the range we like to see for a strong safety).  Thompson should, based on the numbers, be capable of outperforming Collins in coverage.  Really, I see no area in which Collins is a better physical specimen to attach my family's financial hopes and dreams to.

Still, there seems to be a surprising lack of interest in Thompson, and I have to worry about whether he will be given much of an opportunity.  My future of sipping margaritas by the side of the pool really hinges on the possibility that he will get a legitimate chance to compete.  Well, there's that, and hoping my sister doesn't start packing on the pounds, thereby ruining this solid business plan.  So, we have to ask, can Cedric Thompson actually play, or is he just a physically gifted athlete?  Well, let's take a quick look.








As far as potential suitors go, I really see little reason to worry here.  In the games I have watched, Thompson seemed much more consistent at delivering the 'Wow' factor that I am hoping to find in a future groom/drinking buddy.  Collins, on the other hand, seemed to specialize in making me say 'Mehh'.  I may not be a great brother, but even I won't pimp my sister out to a prospect as uninspiring as Collins.

In the end, I have to suspect Thompson can make me my sister quite happy.  The only thing that confuses me, is why people believe that Landon Collins is some sort of special prospect, and Thompson is somebody that can be casually ignored.  If somebody wants to clarify this for me, I'm interested in hearing your arguments.  Then again, the possibility that the world is just ignorant of the brilliance of this 'get rich quick scheme' that I have concocted is the very reason why I may one day be living in the lap of luxury.  Maybe I should just keep my mouth shut about this, until we've got Thompson locked in as a future family member?  I guess I just have to convince my sister of the benefits of this plan, and maybe tart her up a bit.  Don't worry, I'll send wedding invitations to all of you, if this ingenious plot ends up working.



Monday, March 23, 2015

Kangaroo Court: The 2015 Defensive Backs

I'm generally a believer in the idea that the best way to convey a point is through hyperbole, and outright bullshit.  Making a well thought out, and rational argument generally doesn't elicit much interest or attention.  The best debates seem to start with one person making a truly idiotic statement.  So, please allow me to behave like a moron for a moment.

Defensive backs, for the most part, are parasites.  They are blood sucking leeches feeding on the strong healthy body of a defenses' front seven.  Interceptions are superficial flash, and relatively rare events that draw too much attention.  Cornerbacks are overpriced prancing gazelles and ninnies.

If J.J. Watt disrupts an offensive play (producing a sack, or a tackle for a loss, etc.), that's clearly a good thing, and people will probably agree that he beat his opponent.  What if he appears to accomplish nothing, but it took two offensive linemen to stop him?  Well, I think we could say that he still won.  He forced the opposing team to assign more of their resources towards dealing with him, and you can only do that to so many players before you simply lose the game.  Even if he appears to accomplish nothing, Watt has made the job of his fellow linemen that much easier.

Can a defensive back ever accomplish that sort of victory?  Probably not.  At best, they can only occupy the efforts and attention of the one receiver they are matched up against.  When they actually have to confront a truly superior receiver, say Calvin Johnson, it's quite likely they are gong to get significant help from a safety as well, even if they are one of the league's better corners.  The corner's value dwindles and become more debatable.

Of course, it's not just the allocation of on the field resources that can determine whether a play is won or lost, from an efficiency perspective.  Let's think about Byron Maxwell, the Eagles newly acquired cornerback.  For the moment, we'll ignore the possibility that he might have some physical shortcomings that could limit his ability to be significantly better than Cary Williams (who sucks!), whom he replaces at a higher annual cost.  Maxwell is scheduled to be paid approximately $10.5 million per season, for the next five years.  Despite being a 27 year old cornerback, who has only started a total of 17 games in his career, he is going to be paid more than every wide receiver in the NFC East, except for Dez Bryant, who is operating on a franchise tag.  In fact, at least as far as I can tell, there are only 7 wide receivers in the entire NFL, who have an average annual salary that is greater than what Byron Maxwell will receive.  The Eagles are spending more to prevent an outcome from occurring, than their opponents are spending to create an outcome.  If your wife was divorcing you (you had it coming), and threatened to take $7 million of your hard earned dollars (I'm assuming that you smuggle blood diamonds), would you pay a hit man $10 million to make her disappear?  Yes, I realize that this is a stupid comparison, but I still have to question the efficiency of certain types of spending.

Since I tend to write about football from the perspective of avoiding risks, I kind of have an ingrained defensive mind-set.  I'll also acknowledge that there are some truly exceptional defensive backs out there, though they are rare.  Despite being in a more reactive position, some of these players can tilt the outcomes of games more than you might normally expect.  Unfortunately, I suspect that in the nuclear arms race of football, the stockpile of serviceable but not spectacular cornerbacks makes disarmament seem like an appealing option.  Even with a player like Darrelle Revis, who I would agree is truly exceptional, the question of efficient team spending seems unavoidable.  At an average annual salary of $14 million, how often is he going to face an opponent who is actually worthy of his skills, let alone worthy of the financial investment the team has made in him?  Maybe twice a year? 

Okay, so maybe I only half believe this nonsense I've just spouted.  Still, it is something that rattles around in my brain from time to time.  It's not like I can really spend my entire day thinking about the Kentucky meat shower, the Aokigahara suicide forest, or the Hello Kitty murder (seriously, they made a movie based on this, which was titled There Is A Secret In My Soup).  A man can't live on deranged and possibly psychopathic interests alone.

Now, let's kick around some thoughts about this year's group of defensive back draft prospects, much as we did last year.

Besides the player's Agility Score, I will also list their 2nd Gear score, and their average number of passes defended in their last two years in college.  Like the hopefully discrete ladies at the massage parlor, I think a high quality DB should probably be grabbing balls with some frequency.  For safety prospects, my expectations for the Agility Score will go down a bit, but I hope to see an increase in their Kangaroo Score (our measure of lower body power), which is also given in the form of how many standard deviations that a player is away from the average result for someone in their position group.

Let the guessing continue...

This list will continue to be modified and updated as new data, and additional prospects, come to my attention.  Not every prospect will be included here, but instead, just the ones that I find interesting for one reason or another.  Updated: 4/22/15



Trae Waynes  CB, Michigan State  Ht:  6'  Wt.: 186
40 time: 4.32  2nd Gear:  0.21   Agility Score:  -1.141   Avg. PD:  9.5
People like to make fun of Al Davis' love of a great 40 time, but he isn't the only person suffering from this disease.  Because of that, I really don't have to worry about Trae Waynes.  I know that some team will select him, well before Team Kangaroo is on the clock.  While his Agility Score is worrisome, maybe we should consider what his result would be based on his pro day.  With that data, his result comes out to -0.455, which still isn't great, but at least isn't horrifically bad.  Maybe this lack of advanced nimble-osity has something to do with the way that Waynes is constantly grabbing at his opponents.  Personally, I didn't think Waynes looked terrible, but I think his upside is probably similar to someone like Johnathan Joesph, who he has a lot in common with.  Do I think Waynes' potential ceiling truly matches his projected draft status?  I'd have a hard time making that wager, so I'd probably abstain, and let someone else take the gamble.

Landon Collins  SS, Alabama   Ht:  6'  Wt.: 228
40 time: 4.53  2nd Gear:  0.04   Agility Score:  -1.738   Avg. PD:  9
At some point, I'm sure I'll get tired of expressing my doubts about players from Alabama...but not today.  With strong safety prospects, I am normally much less concerned with exceptional Agility Scores, though Collins' result would still make me worry quite a bit.  On the other hand, I do expect a strong safety to make up for this with exceptional power, which his 1.650 Kangaroo Score suggests he does possess.  As far as I can tell, based on the little I have seen of Collins, these numbers line up nicely with what he appears to be.  He seems to be an above average hitter, who probably has below average coverage skills.  To be fair to him, he does seem to play a fairly smart game, and not put himself into positions where his physical shortcomings are exploited as often as they could be.  His statistical production was generally above average, in most areas, so I guess that is one point in his favor.  While I don't find him terribly interesting as a safety prospect, I do wonder if converting him to the linebacker position might work.  He basically plays like one anyway, so it might be worth a shot.  It's highly frustrating to me that Collins will probably get on the field very early in his career, accumulate some stats and therefore some acclaim, and yet the player that I think may be this year's best strong safety prospect might not get drafted at all.

Kevin Johnson  CB, Wake Forest   Ht:  6'0.25"  Wt.: 188
40 time: 4.52  2nd Gear:  0.08   Agility Score:  1.251   Avg. PD:  11
Because of his excellent agility, the computer is sort of prodding us to take Johnson seriously.  Some of his other results also point towards Johnson having rather good lower body power and explosiveness, despite his Kate Moss-like frame.  We only had two fairly minor concerns.  He has fairly mediocre timed speed, though a safety can help with some of that.  He also has fairly small hands (8.375"), which might explain the high numbers of passes he broke up, relative to his number of interceptions.  We might have some minor quibbles and concerns about Johnson, but in the end we still like him.  Among the cornerbacks who are generally considered to be the top 3 prospects (Waynes, Johnson and Peters), he is likely the one that we feel most comfortable with, though he still might not be the best one in the draft.  The main concern we had, based on watching him play, is that he sometimes allowed more space to opposing receivers than we might want to see.  Whether this is a product of his potentially less than ideal speed, is difficult to say.  When he plays up on the line, I felt he looked vastly better.  If he was available in the 2nd round, we would definitely consider him, though it sounds like he will be taken before then.

Marcus Peters  CB, Washington   Ht:  5'11.5"  Wt.: 197
40 time: 4.53  2nd Gear:  0.07   Agility Score:  -0.128   Avg. PD:  12
We tend to be a bit forgiving of players who were supposedly idiots in college (people in glass houses), so we'll just ignore the fact that he was kicked off his team.  For the most part, there is little about Peters' physical traits which I can complain about.  He is basically the definition of an average athlete, compared to other corners.  That's neither a good nor a bad thing.  He's like oatmeal.  Bland, but perfectly capable of keeping you alive.  The only potentially alarming result he had was with his 10-yard splits, where he consistently failed to crack the 1.60 second barrier.  That does bother me a bit.  Outside of the league's larger or more powerful corners, who can get by with simply mauling their opponents, it is quite unusual to see a corner posting that sort of result, and might point to a lack of quickness.  I wouldn't be shocked if Peters turns out to be an okay corner, but I don't see any evidence to support the idea that he is exceptional.  While he makes some flashy plays due to his aggressiveness and willingness to gamble, I really have to wonder if his athleticism will allow him to consistently cover some of the league's better receivers.  Some reasonable expectation of an exceptional outcome from a potential 1st round pick doesn't strike me as an unreasonable demand, so I would have some serious concerns about picking Peters.

Shaq Thompson, S, Washington   Ht:  6"  Wt.: 228
40 time: 4.64  2nd Gear:  0.08   Agility Score:  0.097   Avg. PD:  5
Well, we've considered the possibility of Thompson playing linebacker, and decided that was something we didn't want to do.  As a safety, he strikes us as a much more interesting prospect.  His Kangaroo Score of 1.202 is within the range of what we want to see in a strong safety.  His Agility Score would put him into consideration for either safety position.  Thompson's relatively poor timed speed would probably bounce him out of serious consideration as a free safety.  His struggles with breaking the 1.70 second barrier in the 10-yard split, does cause us some concerns, as that is normally a fairly easy mark to hit for defensive backs.  Okay, so we're stuck with considering him as a strong safety.  Thompson's statistical production was relatively respectable, and he looked like a reasonable (but not awe inspiring) player in the games we watched.  Really, I would tend to suspect that he will turn out to be better than the more highly touted Landon Collins, though that might be damning him with faint praise.  Unfortunately, people seem to be projecting that Thompson could be selected in the late 1st to early 2nd round, which is a bit too rich for our blood.  I just don't value the strong safety position enough for that sort of investment.

P.J. Williams  CB, Florida St.   Ht:  6"  Wt.: 194
40 time: 4.57  2nd Gear:  -0.02   Agility Score:  -0.814   Avg. PD:  10.5
Okey-dokey.  Unimpressive speed?  Check.  Woefully poor agility?  Check.  Failure to make much of a positive impression on us?  Yep, you can check that box as well.  What he does have going for him is some significantly above average power for a corner, with his 0.986 Kangaroo Score, and he seems rather willing to hit people.  I have no doubt that there are many receivers that Williams can pummel into submission, but I would worry about how he will deal with some of the better athletes he will face in the NFL.  He strikes me as someone who is probably better suited to playing safety, though Seattle seems infatuated with using this type of player as a corner.

Quinten Rollins  CB, Miami (Ohio)   Ht:  5'11"  Wt.: 195
40 time: 4.58  2nd Gear:  0.03   Agility Score:  -0.864   Avg. PD:  7*
Let's see here.  He only played one year of college football.  He has poor timed speed.  His results suggest rather sub-par agility.  I also see no real evidence of explosiveness or lower body power in his Kangaroo Score.  So, of course he is being projected as a 2nd round pick.  I think I should just go ahead and get drunk at this point, since that seems to be what everyone else is doing.  If he is selected before the 5th round, I would be shocked.

Jalen Collins  CB, LSU    Ht:  6'1.5"  Wt.: 203
40 time: 4.43  2nd Gear:  0.07   Agility Score:  -0.002   Avg. PD:  6
I really have to wonder if Collins' somewhat above average size is inflating his draft stock more than it really should.  These sorts of size/speed prospects often go a couple of rounds ahead of where they might deserve to be selected.  I suspect NFL scouts are also drawn to large breasted women (no judgments, I swear!).  While there are some inconsistencies hidden within his Agility Score, his overall results are acceptably average.  For a corner of his size, his Kangaroo Score of 0.527 is only moderately impressive, though he struck me as a tad disinclined to get physical with people.  This might be related to why he has been avoiding doing the bench press.  Finally, we have his somewhat below average statistical production.  There's nothing that is unforgivably terrible about Collins results, and I wouldn't be surprised by either a positive or negative outcome, but I just didn't find him to be a terribly interesting player.  If he ends up getting selected as high as some people suggest, he might be more of a roll of the dice than we feel comfortable with.

Byron Jones  CB/S, Connecticut    Ht:  6'1"  Wt.:199
40 time: ?  2nd Gear:  ?   Agility Score:  1.104   Avg. PD:  8.5
I'm going to need a bib for all of this drool.  It's entirely possible that I am an idiot who is getting swept up in the lunacy surrounding Jones' outrageous combine results.  Oh yes, it's a very distinct possibility.  The problem is that so far his data is allowing him to fit into a very rare category of athlete, that has produced players who became extremely unusual cornerbacks.  Comparisons to players like Champ Bailey and Darrelle Revis really aren't entirely unreasonable.  Okay, it's a little unreasonable.  Of course, things don't always work out that way.  A player like Carlos Rogers, as well as a small handful of other less accomplished players also fell into this group.  Still, the potential here is ridiculous.  Athletically, Jones could theoretically be well suited for any position in the secondary, as his insane 2.839 Kangaroo Score suggests some ridiculous lower body power.  Unfortunately, in the very small sample of his games that I was able to look at, he didn't seem inclined to be a physically punishing blunt instrument.  On the other hand, he did look surprisingly natural as a corner in 2014, and his enormous 10" hands made intercepting the ball appear to be effortless.  Still, I do have some concerns.  His level of competition was rather mediocre, and he faced very few quality receivers.  This might be somewhat counterbalanced by how poor Connecticut's pass rush was, which did him no favors.  He's also relatively inexperienced, so his impact may not be immediate, if it ever occurs at all.  It also seems like the potential for acquiring him cheaply has largely evaporated, as his projected draft position keeps rising.  If he was available in the 2nd round, I'd probably have to consider taking him, though I don't think his resume entirely merits it. 

Steven Nelson  CB, Oregon State   Ht:  5'10"  Wt.: 197
40 time: 4.49  2nd Gear:  0.08   Agility Score:  0.408   Avg. PD:  12
He doesn't strike me as a prospect who will terrify opponents, but I suppose he is serviceable.  He is a slightly above average athlete, and appears to have good hands, and a fair bit of scrappiness.  A team could probably do a lot worse, but I wouldn't say he is a rare commodity.  If he is taken somewhere in the middle of the draft, I guess that wouldn't be too bad.

D'Joun Smith  CB, Florida Atlantic   Ht:  5'10"  Wt.: 187
40 time: 4.46  2nd Gear:  0.10   Agility Score:  -0.444   Avg. PD:  14.5
I like to imagine that he is the heir to a large mustard empire.  That's just me though.  Maybe we can get people to start referring to him as Colonel Mustard.  I'd really enjoy that.  Regardless, does everybody else remember when Miami would routinely have players selected in the 1st round, and schools like Florida Atlantic and Central Florida were just afterthoughts?  Then, Miami decided to have standards about the sorts of idiots and criminals that they would allow into their school, and the quality of their team declined, and these other schools rose up from out of nowhere to become somewhat relevant.  Hmm, I wonder where all the idiots and criminals wound up?  Now, I'm not saying that Colonel Mustard is a dimwit or on any most wanted list, but I suspect he was surrounded by a lot of teammates who might fit that description.  It's just a theory.  Either way, D'joun is, for better or for worse, sort of like the majority of the corners in the league.  They might as well sell guys like this in six packs.

Damarious Randall  FS, Arizona St.   Ht:  5'10.75"  Wt.:196
40 time: 4.47  2nd Gear:  0.09   Agility Score:  0.533   Avg. PD:  7.5
He's not terribly big, and his Kangaroo Score of 0.158 isn't very impressive for a safety prospect.  Athletically, he hovers somewhere in between what I would expect to see in a free safety and a cornerback.  Still, he does have reasonably good speed, and his statistical production was above average.  In many ways, Randall reminds me of a less impressive version of last year's prospect Jimmy Ward, whom we also had some questions about where he fit best.  Maybe playing as a team's nickelback might be a good compromise?  Either way, we might like him a tad bit more than his numbers would suggest was wise, and might consider selecting him if he was still around in the 4th round, which is much lower than I generally see him projected to be taken.

Alex Carter  CB, Stanford    Ht:  6'  Wt.: 196
40 time: 4.52  2nd Gear:  0.08   Agility Score:  -0.018   Avg. PD:  9
Among the middle tier, somewhat less heralded cornerback prospects, I think Carter could be one of the more interesting players.  The only catch is, I wouldn't have him playing corner.  I'd move him to the free safety position.  Based upon his timed speed, his average agility, and his above average Kangaroo Score (which was 0.503, though it would be higher if we just looked at his results from the vertical jump), he should be a fairly ideal athlete for that position.  Considering the poor collection of actual free safety prospects that are in this draft class, I think the option of converting corners might be considered a bit more strongly than it normally is.

Josh Shaw  CB/S, USC    Ht:  6'0.5"  Wt.:201
40 time: 4.44  2nd Gear:  0.10   Agility Score:  -0.089   Avg. PD:  9.5
If you aren't discouraged by the possibility that Shaw is probably a moron, he could be a tolerable mid-round pick.  Just remember, at any moment he could injure himself by jumping out of a window, and later claim that he was trying to stop a terrorist attack.  He's got some Jack Bauer in him.  Then again, the NFL and MENSA don't have a lot of overlap in their memberships.  When it comes to his athletic ability, Shaw is a fairly ideal fit to continue playing either safety position.  Besides his speed, and moderate agility, his Kangaroo Score of 0.971 also suggests he has significant lower body power and explosiveness.  As a corner, I think he is significantly less uninteresting.  While he makes an occasional play that makes me say "Wow, the idiot did a good job there!", he also seemed to disappear for long stretches, or occasionally screw up.  Personally, I thought his former teammate T.J. McDonald was a much better and more consistent prospect.  If his reputation as an imbecile impacted his draft status enough to drop him to the 5th round, I might have some moderate interest in him.  It always pays to have a few morons around, just to boost your self esteem.

Jaquiski Tartt  S, Samford   Ht:  6'1.25"  Wt.:221
40 time: 4.54  2nd Gear:  0.08   Agility Score:  -0.723   Avg. PD:  6
We're still trying to wrap our heads around this guy.  It's a bit unusual for a player from his level of competition to become a talked about prospect, and based on the limited number of games we have seen we don't get the hype.  He seems to have the lower body power to be a strong safety, with a 1.563 Kangaroo Score, and his mediocre agility and speed would be adequate for that role.  He just didn't strike us as a very interesting player.  Considering the low level of competition he faced, we would have expected him to be much more dominant than he appeared top be.

Derron Smith  FS, Fresno St.    Ht:  5'10"  Wt.:200
40 time: ?  2nd Gear:  ?   Agility Score:  ?   Avg. PD:  10.5
Still waiting for data.

Gerod Holliman  FS, Louisville   Ht:  6'  Wt.:215
40 time: 4.62  2nd Gear:  -0.04   Agility Score:  -0.997   Avg. PD:  10
A lot of fuss is going to be made of his 14 interceptions in 2014, but outside of that possible statistical anomaly his results weren't terribly amazing.  Beyond his poor Agility Score, his -0.926 Kangaroo Score was also a rather horrific result for a safety.  Drafting Holliman seems like a very bad idea to me.

Ifo Ekpre-Olomu  CB, Oregon   Ht:  5'9"  Wt.:192
40 time: ?  2nd Gear:  ?   Agility Score:  ?   Avg. PD:  10
Because of the knee injury he is dealing with, it seems unlikely that we will ever get the data that we crave.  Still, he is somebody that we're going to try to look into at some point.  

Eric Rowe CB/S, Utah    Ht:  6'0.5"  Wt.:205
40 time: 4.45  2nd Gear:  0.11   Agility Score:  1.202   Avg. PD:  10.5
On paper, Eric Rowe is probably one of the most ideal cornerback prospects in the entire draft, at least based on his athletic ability.  He has size, speed, agility and even power (a 1.164 Kangaroo Score).  Still, for some reason, my nipples only seem to get lukewarm when I watch him play.  Maybe it is his inconsistent backpedal, but he still looks like a safety who is being forced to play cornerback.  Of course, he used to be a safety, so that shouldn't be surprising, and his athletic traits suggest he could be an excellent fit for that position as well.  I'm also annoyed at the relatively low number of turnovers that he was responsible for, though I guess I can live with that.  On the other hand, Rowe seems like a fairly physical player, and his positional versatility has to be seen as a bonus.  If he was still available in the 3rd round, I think I'd be obligated to pick him.  I wouldn't be surprised if some team chose him in the 2nd round though, because of his somewhat rare physical potential.  I'd probably have a hard time feeling comfortable with that sort of a decision, though I might end up needing to consider it.

Ibraheim Campbell, SS, Northwesterm
40 time: 4.52  2nd Gear:  0.08   Agility Score:  0.156   Avg. PD:  7.5
While we generally see him listed as a strong safety, and he plays like a strong safety, I wonder if he would be better suited to becoming a free safety.  His agility seems ideal for this, and he appears to possess good hands for making the interception.  Oddly, his 0.019 Kangaroo Score is well below what I would normally expect to see in a strong safety.  He's a bit of an odd duck.  He didn't blow my mind, but he looked like a smart and solid player.

Clayton Geathers SS, UCF   Ht:  6'1.5"  Wt.:215
40 time: 4.55  2nd Gear:  0.03   Agility Score:  -1.106   Avg. PD:  11
and
Kurtis Drummond SS, Michiigan St.   Ht:  6'0.5"  Wt.:208
40 time: 4.65  2nd Gear:  -0.01   Agility Score:  -1.010   Avg. PD:  12.5
I thought I would just lump these two guys together, since I feel they have a lot in common.  Really, we're just including these players as a point of comparison to the much more costly acquisition of Landon Collins.  Geathers and Clayton have very similar Agility Score, both of which are superior to Collins' result.  Both have at least acceptable speed for a safety, similar to Collins.  Both have good lower body power, with Kangaroo Scores of 1.370 for Geathers, and 1.078 for Drummond, which are slightly lower than Collins, but still ideal results for a strong safety.  When it comes to statistical production, they both turned in good results, though there were some noticeable difference.  While Drummond created more turnovers, Geathers was more of a tackling machine.  In general, I'd say their stats reflected what I saw in the few games that I watched for each player.  Drummond seemed like more of a gambler, while Geathers seemed like more of a conservative and responsible 'man his position' type of guy.  It could come down to a matter of personal preference as to which player suits your tastes.  Either way, I'm not sure that their is a huge gulf between them.  The interesting question to me, is what happens if you watch both of these players, who are generally projected to be late round picks, and then compare them to Landon Collins.  I have a hard time seeing how the more highly rated Collins has any clear edge over either Drummond or Geathers.  Personally, I wouldn't be shocked if both players are better than Collins is.  I wouldn't go so far as to predict stardom for Drummond or Geathers, but I wouldn't be surprised if they turn out to be at least serviceable strong safeties, which wouldn't be a terrible outcome for players generally expected to be selected in the 4th or 5th round.  We still haven't gotten to my favorite safety prospect though (the tension builds!).

JaCorey Shepherd  CB, Kansas   Ht:  5'11"  Wt.:199
40 time: ?  2nd Gear:  ?   Agility Score:  ?   Avg. PD:  17
Still waiting for data.

Adrian Amos  S, Penn State   Ht:  6'0.5"  Wt.: 218
40 time: 4.56  2nd Gear:  0.04   Agility Score:  0.018   Avg. PD:  8
Athletically, he seems like someone who should probably be able to play either safety position.  He has at least adequate agility to play free safety, and the lower body power of a strong safety (1.253 Kangaroo Score).  Based on his statistical production, and the little bit I have seen of him, nothing truly exceptional leapt out at me.  Still, he is a moderately interesting prospect.  I should probably ignore what my lying eyes have to say, and maybe take a shot at him if he is available later in the draft.

Craig Mager  CB, Texas St.   Ht:  5'11.5"  Wt.: 201
40 time: 4.44  2nd Gear:  0.10   Agility Score:  0.533   Avg. PD:  11
Mager strikes me as a very interesting player, at least from the perspective of value.  Does he fit the ideal athletic mold for a corner?  Not exactly, but he's still quite respectable athletically, and much better than many of the bozos who will undoubtedly be selected ahead of him.  The computer also suggests that he has surprising lower body power for a corner, with a 1.045 Kangaroo Score.  As far as I can tell, he's perfectly willing to use that power too.  Mager seems quite willing to lay a m*th*rf*ck*r out.  He actually could be a very interesting safety, though I wouldn't rush to bump him out of the corner position.  Yes, he sometimes makes stupid mistakes.  Yes, his level of competition wasn't so great.  But he is cheap.  Oh, and he's also cheap.  If that doesn't sway you, then I should mention that he will be cheap.  To some extent I think people vastly underestimate how bad most of the league's corners probably are.  All I ask of Mager is that he perform at a reasonably competent level, and I will be quite happy.  Hell, if he gets drafted in the 6th round, as some seem to expect, you could have 20 Mager's for the price of one Byron Maxwell.  I'll take that deal any day of the week.

Justin Coleman  CB, Tennessee   Ht:  5'11"  Wt.: 185
40 time: 4.53  2nd Gear:  0.01   Agility Score:  1.394   Avg. PD:  8.5
Coleman probably has some limitations because of his size and speed, but he still strikes me as one of the better bargains in this draft class.  He may not be a physically overpowering monster, but he does seem to have a fair bit of scrappiness to him.  It's hard for me to imagine that he wouldn't be able to hold on as a team's 3rd or 4th cornerback, at the very least.  Since it's generally expected that he won't be taken until the end of the draft, I'd say there is good value here, and might start to look at him somewhere around the 5th round.

Cedric Thompson SS, Minnesota   Ht:  5'11.5"  Wt.: 211 
40 time: 4.46  2nd Gear:  0.10   Agility Score:  -0.462   Avg. PD:  2.5
Okay, we've now arrived at the player who may be my favorite safety prospect in the entire draft.  While he is sometimes listed as a free safety, I really think it's pretty obvious he is really more of a strong safety.  While his Agility Score, might not appear to be exceptional, it is almost precisely where I start to take strong safety prospects very seriously.  For a free safety, it would be a bit mehhh.  Fortunately, his excellent 1.605 Kangaroo Score, suggests that Thompson does have the sort of lower body power play this role as the hitter of a team's secondary.  When I went to watch clips of Thompson, I have to say I was a bit stunned.  Every now and then, a player will just pop out at me, and set my nipples ablaze.  While I would only describe Thompson's coverage skills as maybe average to fairly good (which is fitting, considering his Agility Score), that's not a huge concern to me.  Remember now, we're talking about a strong safety.  As a hitter and tackler, however, I thought this guy was simply electrifying.  There was just a real explosiveness to how he played, and if he got his hands on an opponent, they were going down.  In the past two years, he either led, or came in second, for team tackles on the Minnesota defense, and I have to strongly suspect he was the best player they had.  Yet, despite that, most places seem to list him as someone who could go undrafted.  I honestly think I could make an argument for this guy going in the 2nd round, but if I can acquire him for significantly less than that, so be it.  I have to admit, I am somewhat smitten.

Darryl Roberts CB, Marshall   Ht:  5'10.5"  Wt.: 177 
40 time: 4.38  2nd Gear:  0.10   Agility Score:  0.994   Avg. PD:  13.5
If you aren't worried about his lack of mass, and the possible injury concerns that go with this, Roberts is a very interesting cornerback prospect.  We haven't been able to watch him play very much, but with his speed, explosiveness, and agility it would seem unlikely that he couldn't compete for a team's nickel corner job, at the very least.  While he's gotten his hands on a lot of passes, he probably hasn't turned as many of them into interceptions as we might like, but that's being a bit nit-picky.  I generally see people listing him as a player who won't be taken before the very end of the draft, so there could be good value here, for very little investment.

Cameron Ontko SS/FS, Cal Poly  Ht:  5'10.5"  Wt.: 222
40 time: 4.48  2nd Gear:  0.11   Agility Score:  0.475   Avg. PD:  2
Reilly and I ran across Ontko very late in our search for prospects, but we really need to add him to the list.  Ontko is a very weird prospect.  He has only played at Cal Poly for the last 2 seasons, and prior to that was at Wisconsin where he got almost no playing time.  While he is listed as a linebacker, his size would probably make him a better fit as a safety.  His agility and speed are a perfectly fine fit for the free safety position, but his ridiculous Kangaroo Score of 2.172 could also make him very interesting as a strong safety, which is somewhat closer to the role he appeared to play for Cal Poly.  In his final season he had 108 tackle, 6.5 tackles for a loss, 1 sack, 3 passes broken up and 1 interception.  He's a very interesting prospect, unfortunately there seem to be some unpleasant rumors about why he left Wisconsin.

Josh Furman FS/SS, Oklahoma St.   Ht:  6'2.25"  Wt.: 210 
40 time: 4.48  2nd Gear:  0.10   Agility Score:  -0.051   Avg. PD:  4*
Here's a prospect who is a complete mystery to me.  As far as I can tell, this past season was the only time he was ever used as a starter, though this was only after he transferred from Michigan.  In this one season, he produced 14 tackles for a loss, and 7 sacks, along with 4 passes broken up, 1 interception, and 1 forced fumble.  Beyond his very good speed, and agility that might make him a good fit at either safety position, he also has a Kangaroo Score of 1.272, which is very promising.  The problem is, I have no idea who this guy is, and I'm not thrilled by the fact that he will already be turning 24 in November.  Still, his physical potential is very interesting.  If someone wants to help fill in the blanks on this guy, feel free to offer me some sort of clue.